• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Email: accace@accace.com

Contact us
Sign up for news
  • Locations
  • Websites
    • Global (English)
    • Global (German)
    • Czech Republic
    • Germany
    • Hungary
    • Poland
    • Romania
    • Russia
    • Slovakia
    • South Africa
    • Ukraine
    • United States of America (USA)
  • eShop

Accace - Outsourcing and advisory services

  • Services
    • OUTSOURCING
    • Accounting and reporting
    • Accounting online portal
    • Payroll and HR administration
    • Payroll and HR online portal
    • Time and attendance online portal
    • ADVISORY
    • Tax advisory
    • Transaction advisory
    • Legal advisory
    • Corporate and secretarial
    • Advisory online portal
    • MARKET ENTRY SUPPORT
  • COVID-19
  • About us
    • Who we are
    • Case studies
    • Meet our key People
    • Partner with us
    • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Careers
    • Open positions
    • Who we are
    • Our values
    • Success stories
    • How we care
    • How we act
    • We volunteer
  • Newsroom
  • Events
  • Locations

Judgment of the European Court of Justice regarding right to refund of VAT | News Flash

2 Jul 2018

Download PDF

Judgment-of-the-European-Court-of-Justice-regarding-right-to-refund-of-VATWe would like to draw your attention to the very interesting judgement of the European Court of Justice (hereinafter the „ECJ“) on tax matters, which was decided during April 2018. The ECJ dealt with the case of a Romanian company that required the VAT refund for transactions relating to a tax period that has already been the subject of a tax inspection which has concluded. Below we are giving you a more detailed description of the situation.

The principle of unity of tax inspections

In the judgement case Nr. C-81/17 Zabrus from April 26, 2018 the ECJ is dealing with the question whether the national regulation, which denies the assessment and recognition of the right to reimbursement of VAT concerning transactions carried out during a period, which has already been the subject of a tax inspection, is compatible with the EU VAT Directive.

Zabrus was subject to a VAT inspection for a part of year 2014, whereby this VAT inspection was concluded in the beginning of year 2015. Zabrus filed a corrective VAT return in May 2015 for the period which had already been subject to a VAT inspection and claimed higher right to VAT deduction. Zabrus was able to support their claim by relevant documents. Tax authorities refused to reimburse the VAT amounts on the ground that claimed sums related to transactions carried out during a tax period, which had already been subject to VAT inspection. They stated that, in accordance with the applicable national legislation, the principle of the unity of tax inspections precluded the reimbursement of the amounts requested by Zabrus because, in respect of the period already subject to inspection, no irregularity concerning VAT contributions had been found and the relevant authorities did not adopt any measure laying down steps to be taken by Zabrus. Zabrus applied for annulment of the decision of the Directorate-General. In its application, Zabrus stated that the deduction of VAT is a taxpayer’s right, which cannot be restricted if the substantive requirements are satisfied, even if certain formal requirements have not been complied with.

According to Romanian law a tax payer may correct errors in a VAT return within the limitation period of five years.  A tax inspection shall be carried out only once for each tax period. It shall not be permitted to correct a VAT return for tax period that has already been subject to a tax inspection, unless other institutions do not discover new information and do not initiate repeated tax inspection. Regional court dismissed the action on the ground that in this case was no new information found, thus it was not possible to request the correction of VAT return. For the incorrect records is liable only Zabrus themselves.

The principle of effectivity

ECJ confirms that the right of deduction is a fundamental principle of the common system of VAT, it is subject to compliance with the substantive and formal conditions laid down by the VAT Directive and may not be limited. Based on the principle of effectiveness it is not possible to deny a taxable person the opportunity to correct their VAT returns when they have been subject of a tax inspection. ECJ took into account the fact that according to respective Romanian regulation there is a significant limitation of right of deduction as opposed to general limitation period of five years for application of right to correct the VAT.

The principle of neutrality

The principle of VAT neutrality also requires that the deduction of input tax shall be allowed, if the substantive requirements are satisfied, even if the taxable person has failed to comply with some of the formal requirements.  Penalty consisting of an absolute refusal of the right of deduction appears disproportionate where no evasion or detriment to the budget of the state is ascertained.

In the Slovak Republic, according to §16 Section 8 of Tax Procedure Code, tax may be decreased, or an excessive deduction increased, on the basis of a supplementary tax return only due application of facts that were not subject to a tax inspection. In case of use of a document, which was not subject to tax inspection, supplementary VAT return can be submitted and VAT deduction from such document can be applied. This judgment may lead to conclusion that from document, which was already subject to tax inspection, the possibility to supplementary deduction of VAT is not excluded if the substantive conditions for deduction are met. However, when the document was subject to a tax inspection, it should be included in results of tax inspection. For this reason, instead of supplementary tax return, it is more appropriate and safer to handle tax inspection and results with due care and if necessary use ordinary and extraordinary legal remedies. We do not recommend to rely on supplementary VAT return, unless later new facts or documents were found.

Let’s talk about how we can work together in Slovakia!

CONTACT

Radislav Bibel
Tax Manager | Accace SLovakia
Tel: +420 725 582 896
E-mail: Radislav.Bibel@accace.com

Related news

What impacts does the 2021 Czech tax package have on the taxation of natural persons in practice? | News Flash

on 20 January 2021, in Czech Republic, News Flash, Other industries, Regional Studies, Taxation
Read more

2021 Tax Guideline for the Czech Republic

on 19 January 2021, in Country guidelines and eBooks, Czech Republic, Taxation
Read more

Value-added tax in the Czech Republic | eBook

on 08 January 2021, in Country guidelines and eBooks, Czech Republic, Taxation
Read more

Labour Law and Employment in the Czech Republic – 2021 Guide

on 07 January 2021, in Country guidelines and eBooks, Czech Republic, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

2021 Transfer Pricing Overview for the Czech Republic

on 07 January 2021, in Country guidelines and eBooks, Czech Republic, International transactions
Read more

2021 Tax Calendar | Czech Republic

on 07 January 2021, in Calendars, Czech Republic, Other industries, Taxation
Read more

Changes in travel reimbursement in the Czech Republic from 1 January 2021 | News Flash

on 05 January 2021, in Czech Republic, News Flash, Other industries, Payroll, HR and Labour Law, Regional Studies
Read more

Minimum, average and guaranteed wage for 2021 in the Czech Republic | News Flash

on 04 January 2021, in Czech Republic, Local news, News Flash, Other industries, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

Czech Tax Package 2021: Overview of Proposed Changes | News Flash

on 10 December 2020, in Czech Republic, Local news, News Flash, Other industries, Taxation
Read more

Hard Brexit from the Czech point of view: VAT and customs duty application from 1.1.2021 | News Flash

on 09 December 2020, in Czech Republic, Local news, News Flash, Other industries, Taxation
Read more

Doing business in the Czech Republic is about to get easier | weBlog

on 19 November 2020, in Articles and expert opinions, Czech Republic, Local news, Other industries, WeBlog
Read more

Czech approach to the impacts of Brexit on premiums as of January 2021 | News Flash

on 13 November 2020, in Czech Republic, Local news, News Flash, Other industries, Taxation
Read more

Abolition of real estate acquisition tax and planned tax amendment for 2021 in the Czech Republic | News Flash

on 15 October 2020, in Czech Republic, Local news, News Flash, Other industries, Taxation
Read more

How to correctly calculate the average earnings in the Czech Republic? | News Flash

on 05 October 2020, in Czech Republic, News Flash, News per country, Other industries, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

Coronavirus from the perspective of Czech labour law | eBook

on 19 March 2020, in Country guidelines and eBooks, COVID, Czech Republic, Local news, Other industries, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

Report on relations in the Czech Republic

on 16 March 2020, in Accounting and finance, Czech Republic, Legal and corporate, Local news
Read more

2020 Company Formation in the Czech Republic

on 24 January 2020, in Country guidelines and eBooks, Czech Republic, Legal and corporate
Read more

“Quick fixes“ – VAT news for 2020 in the Czech Republic | News Flash

on 22 January 2020, in Czech Republic, News Flash, Other industries, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

Czech reporting obligation for income paid abroad – reminder | News Flash

on 08 January 2020, in Czech Republic, News Flash, Other industries, Regional Studies, Taxation
Read more

2020 payroll calculator for the Czech Republic

on 04 January 2020, in CALCULATORS 2020, Czech Republic, Payroll, HR and Labour Law
Read more

Primary Sidebar

<< Back to newsroom

NEW TO THE MARKET?

Use the free consultancy delivered by our in-country experts to get you prepared.

See what is included and schedule your call now!

We only need your email

Footer

About Accace

Originally established in Central and Eastern Europe in 2006, Accace ranks among the leading outsourcing and consultancy providers in the region. Engaging over 600 experts, we have vast experience with handling small to large scale, multi-country outsourcing projects and providing a comprehensive range of our services to over 2,000 customers.

About Accace Circle

Accace operates internationally as Accace Circle, a co-created business community of like-minded BPO providers and advisors who deliver outstanding services with elevated customer experience. Covering almost 40 jurisdictions with over 2,000 professionals, we support more than 10,000 customers, mostly mid-size and international Fortune 500 companies from various sectors, and process at least 170,000 pay slips globally.

Locations and contacts | Accace Circle

Our services

Accounting and reporting
Payroll and HR administration
Tax advisory
Transaction advisory
Legal advisory
Corporate and secretarial

Our eShop

Market entry support
See full list of services

Our online portals

Accounting portal
Payroll and HR portal
T&A portal
Advisory portal

Get in touch with us

Locations and contacts
Contact us
Sign up for news
Newsroom
Careers


Follow us

Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Instagram Youtube


Accace Circle

© Accace all rights reserved | Code of conduct | General Disclaimer | Disclaimer Newsroom | Cookie policy | Privacy policy | GDPR Statement

Get free access to
valuable insights
expert knowledge

Our legislation updates make it easy for you to keep on top of the latest changes affecting your business. Receive our articles, opinions, tips, industry news, country profiles, regional overviews and studies, latest events and even more, directly into your mailbox.

Check out our Newsroom to see what is included!

We only need your email

We will send you only relevant information we consider may be of your interest and treat your personal data in compliance with our Privacy policy and GDPR statement.

Unable to subscribe?  Try this page.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more.